Effect of donor nephrectomy time during circulatory-dead donor kidney retrieval on transplant graft failure.

BACKGROUND: When the blood supply ceases in a deceased organ donor, ischaemic injury starts. Kidneys are cooled to reduce cellular metabolism and minimize ischaemic injury. This cooling is slow and kidneys are lukewarm during nephrectomy. Smaller single-centre studies have shown that prolonged donor nephrectomy time decreases early kidney transplant function, but the effect on long-term outcome has never been investigated in large multicentre cohort studies. METHODS: The relationship between donor nephrectomy time and death-censored graft survival was evaluated in recipients of single adult-to-adult, first-time deceased-donor kidneys transplanted in the Eurotransplant region between 2004 and 2013. RESULTS: A total of 13 914 recipients were included. Median donor nephrectomy time was 51 (i.q.r. 39-65) min. Kidneys donated after circulatory death had longer nephrectomy times than those from brain-dead donors: median 57 (43-78) versus 50 (39-64) min respectively (P < 0·001). Donor nephrectomy time was independently associated with graft loss when kidneys were donated after circulatory death: adjusted hazard ratio (HR) 1·05 (95 per cent c.i. 1·01 to 1·09) per 10-min increase (P = 0·026). The magnitude of this effect was comparable to the effect of each hour of additional cold ischaemia: HR 1·04 (1·01 to 1·07) per h (P = 0·004). For kidneys donated after brain death, there was no effect of nephrectomy time on graft survival: adjusted HR 1·01 (0·98 to 1·04) per 10 min (P = 0·464). CONCLUSION: Prolonged donor nephrectomy time impairs graft outcome in kidneys donated after circulatory death. Keeping this short, together with efficient cooling during nephrectomy, might improve outcome.

ANTECEDENTES: La lesión por isquemia empieza en el momento que cesa la irrigación sanguínea del órgano donante. Para reducir el metabolismo celular y la lesión isquémica se reduce la temperatura de los riñones. Este enfriamiento es lento y los riñones se mantienen tibios durante la nefrectomía. Estudios unicéntricos con muestras pequeñas han demostrado que el tiempo de la nefrectomía del donante disminuye la función precoz del injerto renal, pero nunca se ha analizado su repercusión a largo plazo en grandes estudios multicéntricos. MÉTODOS: Se analizó la relación entre la duración de la nefrectomía del donante y la supervivencia del injerto en 13.914 adultos receptores de un primer riñón procedente de donante cadavérico adulto en la región de Eurotransplant entre los años 2004 y 2013. RESULTADOS: La mediana de duración de la nefrectomía del donante fue de 51 minutos (rango intercuartílico 39-65). En los riñones obtenidos en donantes a corazón parado la duración de la nefrectomía fue más prolongada que en los donantes en muerte cerebral (mediana 57 min (43-78 min) versus 50 min (39-64 min), P < 0,001). La duración de la nefrectomía en el donante se asoció de forma independiente con la pérdida del injerto (cociente de riesgos instantáneos, hazard ratio, HR, ajustado 1,05 por cada incremento de 10 minutos, i.c. del 95%: 1,01 a 1,09; P = 0,026) cuando los riñones se obtuvieron en donantes en parada cardíaca. La magnitud de este efecto fue comparable al efecto de cada hora adicional de isquemia fría (1,04, i.c. 95% 1,01-1,07, P = 0,004). En los riñones obtenidos de donantes en muerte cerebral, la duración de la nefrectomía no influyó en la supervivencia del injerto (HR ajustada 1,01 por aumento de 10 min, i.c. del 95%: 0,98 a 1,04). CONCLUSIÓN: La duración de la nefrectomía en donantes a corazón parado afecta la función de los injertos trasplantados. Reducir esta duración y disponer de un sistema de enfriamiento eficiente durante la nefrectomía podría mejorar los resultados.

The duration of asystolic ischemia determines the risk of graft failure after circulatory-dead donor kidney transplantation: A Eurotransplant cohort study.

Circulatory death donor (DCD) kidney transplantations are steadily increasing. Consensus reports recommend limiting donor warm ischemia time (DWIT) in DCD donation, although an independent effect on graft outcome has not been demonstrated. We investigated death-censored graft survival in 18 065 recipients of deceased-donor kidney transplants in the Eurotransplant region: 1059 DCD and 17 006 brain-dead donor (DBD) kidney recipients. DWIT was defined as time from circulatory arrest until cold flush. DCD donation was an independent risk factor for graft failure (adjusted hazard ratio [HR] 1.28, 95% CI 1.10-1.46), due to an increased risk of primary nonfunction (62/1059 vs 560/17 006; P < .0001). With DWIT in the model, DCD donation was no longer a risk factor, demonstrating that DWIT explains the inferior graft survival of DCD kidneys. Indeed, DCD transplants with short DWIT have graft survival comparable to that of standard-criteria DBD transplants (P = .59). DWIT also associated with graft failure in DCDs (adjusted HR 1.20 per 10-minute increase, 95% CI 1.03-1.42). At 5 years after transplantation, graft failure occurred in 14 of 133 recipients (10.5%) with DWIT <10 minutes, 139 of 555 recipients (25.0%) with DWIT between 10 and 19 minutes, and 117 of 371 recipients (31.5%) with DWIT ≥20 minutes. These findings support the expert opinion-based guidelines to limit DWIT.

The Impact of Anastomosis Time During Kidney Transplantation on Graft Loss: A Eurotransplant Cohort Study.

Recent studies raised the concern that warm ischemia during completion of vascular anastomoses in kidney implantation harms the transplant, but its precise impact on outcome and its interaction with other risk factors remain to be established. We investigated the relationship between anastomosis time and graft survival at 5 years after transplantation in 13 964 recipients of deceased donor solitary kidney transplants in the Eurotransplant region. Anastomosis time was independently associated with graft loss after adjusting for other risk factors (adjusted hazard ratio [HR] 1.10 for every 10-min increase, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.06-1.14; p < 0.0001), whereas it did not influence recipient survival (HR 1.00, 95% CI 0.97-1.02). Kidneys from donation after circulatory death (DCD) were less tolerant of prolonged anastomosis time than kidneys from donation after brain death (p = 0.02 for interaction). The additive effect of anastomosis time with donor warm ischemia time (WIT) explains this observation because DCD status was no longer associated with graft survival when adjusted for this summed WIT, and there was no interaction between DCD status and summed WIT. Time to create the vascular anastomoses in kidney transplantation is associated with inferior transplant outcome, especially in recipients of DCD kidneys.